College Media Network - Search the largest news resource for college students by college students Jobs and internships for students -

The Common Cause: A great tragedy could get worse

Published: Tuesday, November 10, 2009

Updated: Tuesday, November 10, 2009 01:11

Unless you live in a hole in the ground you know about the tragedy that took place November 5, 2009 at Fort Hood, Texas. The facts that have been released to the public show at least thirteen were killed and many remain in the hospital. These deaths are tragic, but the situation isn’t over yet.

Maj. Nidal Malik Hasan is a member of the Muslim faith. As news was being reported by various news agencies something caught my attention. A show on Fox News titled “Fox and Friends” began to discuss the shooting from a different angle. The people on the show placed the focus on Islam, and began to suggest that the actions of Maj. Hasan were acceptable to Islamic faith. They went on to suggest that Muslim members of the military probably have special screenings or debriefings to serve their own country, The United States of America.

I would like to tell you plainly that Islam does not condone the actions of Hasan. The Muslim Association of Huntington issued a statement that day condemning the actions. Islam is not a religion of hate.

We need to put this into perspective for a moment. You may remember in the early summer when a man named Scott Roeder claiming to be a Christian murdered Dr. George Tiller in his own church. Roeder is no more a good Christian than Major Hasan is a good Muslim.

Neither religion teaches the practice of murder.

Timothy McVeigh was a Christian, he committed a terrorist act on American soil through the Oklahoma City bombing. The Israeli soldiers who picked up young teenage boys and used them as human shields during the aggression against Palestine last winter, did Yahweh ask them to do that?

These are not isolated incidents. All of the major religions have had both common practice and extremists commit horrible atrocities throughout history to now. Anyone that doesn’t admit that their religion has committed (and in extremist instances continues to) terrible acts is lying to themselves.

Should all Christians or Jews have to go through a special screening like “Fox and Friends,” suggested Muslims should have to.

No.

This nation was not founded on any religion; most of the Founding Fathers were Deists, which is one step from modern Atheism. This nation is founded on freedom of religion and the practice of any religion should not make you subject to special treatment, in favor as many Christians would want, or in bigotry of Islam, again as many fundamentalist Christians would want.

This tragedy is bad enough, lets not make it worse. Do not let bigotry and hate creep into your mind. Hasan is no more a representation of Islam as a whole then I am a representation of Marshall as a whole.  Major Hasan has committed a terrible crime. We should not blame anyone but him or those that helped him. Islam as a religion did not support his crime, don’t place the blame on it. Bigotry will only make this tragedy worse for us all who must find a way to progress together.

Recommended: Articles that may interest you

7 comments

John
Mon Nov 16 2009 04:39
I have to agree with the premise of the last post, but there are some things that need to be pointed out. There are radicals in every religion - including Christianity. Timothy McVeigh didn't have direct ties to a religious organization, but he was loosly associated with white supremacist groups, which base their beliefs on the idea that they are God's chosen people. And yes, there are plenty of other Christian extremists out there - how about the extremists that bomb abortion clinics and shoot doctors? While I may not belive in abortion, I don't think taking another's life is the answer, either. We will all be judged someday, and I have a hard time believing God will show mercy on someone that kills our unborn, but that's not for me to decide.

But the point is, right now, radical Muslims are this country's biggest threat. We ought not ignore that fact in the face of political correctness.

Your name
Sat Nov 14 2009 14:43
How clear does it have to be.
The man engaged in Islamic extremist behavior, spoke of suicide bombings as being positive things and shouted out "Allah Akbar" right before killing and injuring innocent people.
When was the last time somebody shouted out "Praise Jesus" before gunning down innocent people?

It was a terrorist act because it was politically and religiously motivated. It mimicks the terrorist acts done around the world all with the same connections and the same religion.

You need to fact check before making claims as Israeli soliders never used anyone as "human shields." I believe the "palestinians" who herded their children into areas where Israel declared they would attack (places holding weapons) would be a better description of "human shields."

The line that "not ALL Muslims..." is getting old.
Clearly not "all" muslims are terrorists...a minority goes around blowing things up for their religion...
However, the majority DO condone it by not speaking out, by not acting out and not stopping it. Sure the Muslim association will send out a message saying that this particular action was wrong. But why don't they protest over the horrible treatment of women, children, Jews and gays the Muslim world? Why do people have to die before they speak out?

And THAT is the point. We don't just blame Hitler and the Nazi soliders for the Holocaust. We also blame every average citizen who did nothing and watched it happen. And that is what the Muslim world is doing. The average citizens who would never harm a soul allow their religious and political leaders to do horrible acts of violence in the name of their religion.

But that is honestly besides the point.
The point is not that "not all muslims" are terrorists...we get that.
So why can't we talk about the ones that are?

How exactly did an American born man who got a PH.D in Psychology and who joined the military get radicalized to do this? THAT is what we have to pay attention to.

Yes we should screen everyone who enters the military...had we not been so afraid of political correctness this man would have been discharged before he could kill anyone.

Jews do NOT kill people for their religion. They never have and they never will. There is simply nothing in Judaism to support that.

Timothy McVeigh had no religious motivation for the bombing.
Yes people who shoot abortion doctors may be Christians but they don't follow a pattern of shouting out "Praise G-d" before doing so.

We have a very well established pattern of Muslim terrorism and this man followed that pattern. And if you didn't notice many Muslim organizations, leaders and internet bloggers enthusiastically praised his actions in the name of Islam.

Islam may not "support this crime" but millions upon millions of its followers do.

This man did not try to rob a bank. He did not try to kill someone who slept with his wife. He did not kill soliders because he was disgruntled or stressed.

He engaged in Islamic extremism. He was born in America but called himself a "Palestinian." He stated that Muslims should be exempt from serving their country because they shouldn't have to attack other Muslims or Muslim countries. He praised suicide bombings. He called the war on terror a war on Islam and he walked calmly into a room of innocent medical soliders, shouted out "Allah Akbar" and then killed them.

How much more clear does it have to be?

John
Fri Nov 13 2009 04:28
Would love for people to be informed about the Muslim faith. While Hasan's actions certainly don't speak for every Muslim, the reality is that there is a very strong and very large wing of Islam that in fact DOES promote violence as a way to promote its brand of jihad. Ever hear of al Qaeda? The Taliban? These are not teeny, tiny organizations with just a few extremists. This is an entire movement that has two main purposes. The destruction of Israel by any means necessary, and the destruction of western influences into the Middle East. We have become so careful to 'not offend' this religion, but the fact is - in the past decade, more people have been killed in more terror attacks by Muslim extremists than any other religious or political group around the globe. Sure, let's not unfairly target Muslims who don't engage in these tactics, but at the same time, we cannot afford to turn a blind eye to the fact that this religion is producing terrorists.
Your name
Wed Nov 11 2009 02:47
"Anyone that doesn’t admit that their religion has committed (and in extremist instances continues to) terrible acts is lying to themselves."

No religion has ever committed a terrible act. What a terrible sentence. No, I don't believe my religion has ever committed a terrible act as a whole as this sentence suggests. I do believe that people have said they are a part of a religion, committed terrible acts and made an entire religion look bad, however. HUGE difference.

Ashley
Tue Nov 10 2009 13:58
As a government employee that works at an Army installation that in processes soldiers into Basic Training I can tell you that "Fox and Friends" is wrong. I screen through every file and medical record of every soldier that comes through our installation and there is no special questionnaire or form for those of a particular faith. The only time a soldier’s religion is asked is when we make their ID tags (dog tags) so that in the event of their death they can receive the last words or rights that they believe in. We do not have enough time to question each soldier with a certain faith. They already spend 20 hours a day doing as much in processing as possible so that they can start Basic Training on time. Every day I see soldiers that are Muslims, Christians, Jews, and Wiccans etc. They are not treated any differently based on their faith.
Jay Roudebush II
Tue Nov 10 2009 13:29
I wonder what Jesus would say in response to your post good reverend. I would imagine the hate speech you are offering is the cause of so many people turning away from Christianity. You suggest people should take judgement into their own hands and murder in the name of God. Basically you Rev. Donald Spitz are the same as Osama Bin Laden. You just said it is ok to murder in the name of your God's law.

Thank you for validating every belief I have towards Christianity. Due to people like you Christianity no longer has anything to do with the message of Jesus, instead it is based around the influence of man.

Rev Donald Spitz
Tue Nov 10 2009 01:51
Scott Roeder did the right thing. He stopped George Tiller from murdering any more children. People like you and the babykiller George Tiller are the terrorists. You murder helpless babies in their mother's womb. Now I know why God created eternal hell fire, for babykilling pro-aborts like you.






log out