College Media Network - Search the largest news resource for college students by college students Jobs and internships for students -

Classmate says Perdue received special treatment because of prominent parents

Published: Thursday, November 19, 2009

Updated: Thursday, November 19, 2009 00:11

The state treasurer’s daughter received special treatment, said a student who took the same class.


Britany Thompson, senior business and math education major from Tolsia, W.Va., also took the Office Management independent study course with professor Laura Wyant of the School of Education and Human Services.


In May, Emily Perdue, daughter of John Perdue, West Virginia state treasurer and Robin Perdue director of the West Virginia Public Employees Grievance Board Director, received two incompletes from Wyant.  Rosalyn Templeton, dean of the school, said she would be instructing Perdue’s remaining work in the summer and assigned two passing grades in September in place of the incompletes.


“It was a lot of work,” Thompson said.  “There were about 25 chapters in that book, and we were supposed to have lesson plans that corresponded with each of the chapters.  I worked on it probably six to eight hours a week.”


Thompson said Perdue did not attend any class meetings during the semester except the first and last class meetings, which she attended with her mother.


Thompson said after the first meeting, she and another student in the class met with Wyant on a weekly basis.


“Emily never came to any of these sessions,” Thompson said.  “She came to the first one, and I didn’t see her again until the last meeting.


“Her mother was at both of the meetings that she attended,” Thompson said.  “I assumed that (her mother) was just a non-traditional student; that’s not uncommon in the Adult and Technical Education program.


“She was taking notes, looking over the syllabus, just like she was enrolled in the class but come to find out it was actually her mother,” Thompson said.


Thompson said Emily Perdue did not take notes during the class.


Wyant said she took a week off in February.


“During that time I had communicated with Emily a little and she said that she’d actually dropped from the class,” Thompson said.


“I don’t think it was an extremely heavy load,” Wyant said.  “However, it did cover the content, and if you’re going to be teaching that content, you have to understand the content.”


“There’s a lot of content to be learned about that,” Thompson said.  “Of course there were times being overwhelmed because I was working, doing my level two clinical, and I had seven courses.”


Thompson said she felt that Perdue received special treatment.


Emily Perdue said she did not have time in the semester to do the work, nor would she have time in the summer to do the work, Wyant said.


“Dr. Templeton asked her why she would not have time in the summer in a very nice way,” Wyant said.  Emily Perdue said she had to work.


“She didn’t even buy the book,” Wyant said.  “She told us on that May 5th that she hadn’t even purchased the book.”


Templeton then asked another faculty member to take the textbook and make copies of it for Emily, Wyant said.


A second source confirms this.


“Rosalyn took the book and gave it to (the source), and (the source) came over and made copies of the first two chapters to give them to Emily because she didn’t have the book,” Wyant said.


Both Wyant and Thompson said the book required was inexpensive.


“I bought it on Amazon for $3.95,” Thompson said.

Staci Standiford can be contacted at standiford1@marshall.edu.

Recommended: Articles that may interest you

8 comments

siddhatt5
Fri Nov 20 2009 18:59
I've been a Marshall faculty member for more than 20 years and have given many independent studies. Some met weekly, some met four or five times during the course of a semester, some met only once or twice. It depends on the purpose of the independent study and the schedule agreed upon by the faculty member and student(s). Often independet studies are given because a course needed to comlete a program of study has too few students for the university to agree to pay for it as a conventional course. So a faculty member teaches teach an extra course free, more work without additional compensation. Minimum course enrollment figures have been sharply increased during the Kopp administration, making independent study offerings more likely to be essential to student progress.
Bret
Thu Nov 19 2009 15:24
What? you are absolutely correct when you said an independent study does that have a set meeting time. This independent study did not have a set meeting time. But when it came to Dr. Wyant's attention at the end of February that we were having trouble she contacted us and set aside time each week when we could come in and get help. It was not a required meeting it was a time for our own benefit. I thank Dr. Wyant for her help and assistant and going the extra mile for students.
Im not surprised
Thu Nov 19 2009 12:36
I graduated from Marshall about a year ago and ever since Tempelton took over things started getting a weird over there. I was like everyone was just waiting on the powder-keg to explode and it looks like it has. I just hope the male students who I've head complaining about the way she treated them don't get involved or the COEHS is going to need to find another Dean....no that it would be a bad thing
Anonymous
Thu Nov 19 2009 12:15
ps the hearing impaired student was forced by the university's indifference to her claims to file a claim in Federal Court/
Anonymous
Thu Nov 19 2009 12:14
The Perdue scandal becomes even more suspicious when considered in light of the hearing impaired student who was forced to file a lawsuit against the University and one of its professors for violation of her rights under federal law as a hearing impaired student. The fact the hearing impaired student was harassed and ridiculed by her professor for even attempting to be a Nurse with a hearing impairment notwithstanding, the University offered this studen no assistance with her claims whatsoever. In spite of the fact she was not provided with the reasonable accommodations to her hearing impairment as required by federal law, the hearing impaired student missed a passing grade by less than one half of one percent. And, in spite of being made aware of the professor's discrimination and violation of federal law, the University blew her father's request for assistance with the professor without even a basic investigation.

Of course her father was not the Treasurer of the State of West Virginia or its Governor. Her father was simply a Joe the Plumber type with no political influience whatsoever.

Marshall mom
Thu Nov 19 2009 10:53
I am a Marshall parent (and former teducator) who is totally perplexed by this whole incident. The fact that ANY parent , regardless of stature, was permitted to be involved to this extent with an adult student's college education is remarkable. I have been told by professors I know personally (from other colleges) that they will not discuss this type of situation with parents unless there are exigent circumstances such as a disability or illness that prevents the adult student from handling the matter for him or herself. If it is found that the changes were made due to the parents' status, it is not only reprehensible but unjust to every student who has ever received a bad grade or incomplete without the second chance Ms. Perdue was given. I hope if she does become an educator she allows every students' parents to convince her to give their kids a second chance even after they never attend her class.
What?
Thu Nov 19 2009 10:43
An independent study (not the very name) does not have set meeting times. Something's fishy with this student's story of what happened.....
Your name
Thu Nov 19 2009 10:38
This isn't the only instance of special treatment. There have been others. I've witnessed them myself. Not in that class, as I didn't take that one, but in another.






log out